“The reason that this is so disruptive is that we have a segregated community,” board member Kathy Shannon said. “If we had a community where rich and poor were regularly mixed throughout the community, we could do traditional boundaries and it wouldn’t matter. Every school would have a relatively equal mix of low and high” socioeconomic status. “And so, I hate that this is going to be very disruptive — this is going to be very hard for people — but I want us to keep in mind that we’re doing this for the good of our students, and long term, maybe we want to think about ways to desegregate our city.”
Detroit was destroyed by school bussing in the 60s and never recovered. The proponents should consult the history books. Fewkibbutzim utopias in history have lasted more than a few years. Even Israeli kibbutzim with relatively homogeneous populations have failed to thrive. “The vast majority of Israel’s 230 or so kibbutzim, when forced in recent decades to choose between ideology and economic survival, Ein Dor opted for “renewal” – a code word for privatization.” https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2018-04-17/ty-article-magazine/.premium/a-tale-of-two-kibbutzim-capitalism-doesnt-always-trump-socialism/0000017f-dbcd-db22-a17f-fffd367b0000.
When dealing with humans we shouldn’t (well) overlook the fact that they are humans. Tribalism is playing fairly well these days.