Editorial: Transfer tax hike is the last thing downtown Chicago needs – Crain’s*

Brandon Johnson addressing the Chicago city council The truth is the tax as currently drafted would hit a lot of people who are far from fat cats, particularly in the residential market. The Bring Chicago Home idea has, not surprisingly, drawn vociferous pushback from commercial real estate owners in particular, who point out — correctly — that this kind of a tax, levied now, would deal a body blow to a downtown office and retail market that’s never fully recovered from the effects of COVID and the work-from-home ethos it engendered.
11 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Poor Taxpayer
9 months ago

If it is the worst possible thing to do it will happen if government has any say. Government always makes the worst choices, that is their job.

debtsor
9 months ago

These are symptoms of Chicago’s larger ‘Tale of Two Cities’ problem. The middle class has mostly fled since the 70’s. The remaining yuppies and DINKS are outvoted by the working classes. 2/3rds of the yuppies and DINKS larp as Marxists, believing they are doing good. Meanwhile, the working class don’t care about Marxism, they just want what the yuppies and DINKS have, and they’re going to take it from them. And now that a Marxist mayor is trying to fulfill his promises to redistribute the wealth, the larping Marxists are suddenly having second thoughts, shocked to find out that class… Read more »

nixit
9 months ago
Reply to  debtsor

And four year-old Aiden/Ainslie will join pregnant mom and dad at many open houses in Evanston and Oak Park.

Riverbender
8 months ago
Reply to  debtsor

working class??? What about the welfare class?

Goodgulf Greyteeth
9 months ago

Everyone of BJ’s proposed “revenue enhancement for ‘root causes’ taxes” is stuck in a minefield of powerful stakeholder opposition, compellingly negative opportunity costs, and uncertain or trivial benefit.

This one, the jet fuel tax, the downtown worker ‘head’ tax, the financial transaction tax, the ‘suburbs’ tax.

They can’t take a step in any direction without hitting a trip-wire or trigger, and getting a leg blown off on their path toward whatever progressive-n-Marxist-n-Anti Capitalist utopia they’re marching toward.

Couldn’t happen to a more deserving group of people, I think…

Old Joe
9 months ago

Folks, the income tax was sold to the public and ratified into th US Constitution in 1913 under the pretense that only rich people would pay it!

mqyl
9 months ago
Reply to  Old Joe

No problem. Chicago will just keep lowering its threshold to define rich people. You’ll wake up one day and find out you’re rich!

nixit
9 months ago

Instead of blanketly dismissing the tax, the opposition should rewrite it to capture only the highest end sales with different tiers based on capacity (sfh, multifamily, high rise) and category (residential, commercial, industrial). Present a “fair and reasonable” alternative that applies the core principle of the original plan that will bring in more revenue but not nearly the amount the advocates want. That forces the advocates into an unreasonable position and leaves them exposed to rational opposing arguments. If the advocates won’t negotiate, then go back to your previous position of dismissing it entirely, except that now you’ve shown them… Read more »

Seen this before
9 months ago
Reply to  nixit

Although a native of Chicago, I lived through the mid-90’s in DC. In 1995, Congress imposed a control board which completely controlled all of DC;’s finances for six years. My law school professor – then a non-voting Democrat member of Congress – actually supported the control board – agreeing with local progressive media gadfly Mark Plotkin that way too much of the budget was focused on distributing income to those who didn’t produce – harshly – makers versus takers with far too many takers – Mayor Barry had evolved into a benefit granting machine and DC had to live on… Read more »

nixit
9 months ago

Without a doubt. But the progs are obsessed with charging more for big dollar properties. Present their idea back to them but in a rational manner using proper tax policy. And when they reject it – and they will – go back to your previous position.

The problem with this transfer tax is that it will do very little to diminish homelessness or whatever else it gets use for – and certainly won’t move an inch to resolve the pension gaps.

Giddyap
9 months ago

BJ The Race Clown needs you money to fund his reparations racket

SIGN UP HERE FOR FREE WIREPOINTS DAILY NEWSLETTER

Home Page Signup
First
Last
Check all you would like to receive:

FOLLOW US

 

WIREPOINTS ORIGINAL STORIES

Chicago Teachers Union contract demands are totally divorced from reality – Wirepoints

Details emerging about Chicago Teachers Union’s upcoming contract show just how divorced its demands, both extreme and expensive, are from the reality at Chicago schools. It’s not just about massive salary increases, but also about money for migrant students, climate initiatives, abortions and gender-affirming care. About blocking parental notification. Count on CTU’s demands to veer further from reality until the public finally says no. 

Read More »

Gov. Pritzker’s ‘ethics reform’ eliminates competitive elections and choice for voters – Wirepoints on AM 560 Chicago’s Morning Answer

Ted joined Dan and Amy to talk about a new law passed by the Democratic supermajority and signed by Gov. J.B. Pritzker that results in brazen election interference, keeping Republicans off ballots; about a referendum that tests the waters for a renewed progressive income tax hike; about how the Parental Notification referendum question was knocked off the ballot; and why laws like that pass so easily.

Read More »

Chicago needs more champions of literacy like Willie Wilson – Wirepoints

It’s rare to see city leaders in Chicago take an open, unabashed stance on the collapse of literacy. To complain is deemed as too political, too racist or too anti-public schools. So it’s refreshing to see Willie Wilson, a successful businessman and leader of the black community, call for a literacy initiative “with the goal of getting 100% of Black students reading at grade level.”

Read More »

WE’RE A NONPROFIT AND YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS ARE DEDUCTIBLE.

SEARCH ALL HISTORY

CONTACT / TERMS OF USE