By: Mark Glennon*
The dam finally broke.
Most Americans of every political stripe gagged last week seeing three leading university presidents’ Congressional testimony on anti-semitism. After years of punishment and censorship of centrist and conservative viewpoints at their schools and others across America, none of the three could say that calls for genocide against Jews violated their schools’ codes of conduct.
America saw through the hypocrisy — and many saw its root cause as well, which is the diversity equity and inclusion (DEI) bureaucracy dominating most schools. The left’s Fareed Zakaria, writing at CNN, was among them, putting it this way:
People sense the transformation…. Having coddled so many student groups for so long, university administrators found themselves squirming…. What we saw in the House hearing this week was the inevitable result of decades of the politicization of universities. Out of this culture of diversity has grown the collection of ideas and practices that we have all now heard of — safe spaces, trigger warnings, and micro aggressions…. America’s top colleges are no longer seen as bastions of excellence but as partisan outfits, which means they will keep getting buffeted by these political storms as they emerge.
Universities face a reckoning. The University of Pennsylvania’s president already lost her job over it. Others likely will follow. The University of Wisconsin perhaps figured this out. On Friday, it announced a deal with critics that would freeze hiring for diversity positions through the end of 2026 and shift at least 43 diversity positions to focus on “student success.” The system also would eliminate any statements supporting diversity on student applications. However, the Board of Regents rejected the deal on Saturday.
Perhaps most impactful, donors have revolted, and if anything gets the attention of university bureaucrats it’s money.
It’s time for universities to do what’s right, which happens also happens to be in their own interest.
Among Illinois schools, one maintains a policy that most conspicuously enforces the culture of DEI oppression Zakaria described. That’s the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign with its mandatory DEI loyalty policy for faculty. It’s called Communication 9 and was finalized earlier this year. It’s summarized here and detailed here. Compliance is “optional” currently but becomes mandatory in two years.
It’s particularly egregious because it goes further than demanding agreement with DEI principles: It mandates DEI work and requires annual statements demonstrating that work. Going forward evaluations, promotions and tenure decisions must be based in part on the adequacy of the DEI work performed, Communication 9 says. It doesn’t matter what field one is in; all faculty are bound by it.
“Engage in DEI activism, or else.” That’s how The College Fix put it in their headline when Communication 9 was in draft last year.
The policy even mandates use of woke language in the required personal DEI statements: “Candidates should be sensitive about the use of language that perpetuate prejudices and words that apply external value judgments that minimize the experiences, strengths, and contributions of individuals and/or groups historically marginalized and/or underrepresented in academia.”
“It is important that candidates avoid statements that overgeneralize or make sweeping claims about a group of people,” says the policy. (It’s safe to assume, however, that wouldn’t apply to claims like “Whiteness prevents white people from connecting to humanity,” which we hear from DEI champions like Ingram X. Kendi.)
Communication 9 begs for litigation as a violation of the First Amendment, as we wrote when it was in draft. It’s a classic example of unconstitutional “forced speech.” Two First Amendment experts we spoke to compared it to unconstitutional loyalty oaths required during the years of McCarthyism.
Ending Communication 9 would also help cut some of the DEI administrative bloat that plagues U of I, which is among the worst on that count. It ranks seventh highest in the nation with 71 DEI staff, according to a Heritage Foundation study we reported on last year.
“A review of salary data shows that the universities of Michigan, Maryland, Virginia and Illinois, plus Virginia Tech, boast some of the highest-paid DEI staffers at public universities,” said a Fox News column on that study. “These institutions’ top diversity employees earn salaries ranging from $329,000 to $430,000 – vastly eclipsing the average pay for the schools’ full-time tenured professors.” Sean C. Garrick, vice chancellor for diversity, equity and inclusion at the University of Illinois, earned nearly $330,000 annually, salary disclosures showed, according to the Fox column. But the average Illinois full-time professor salary hovers only around $152,000, Fox said.
Many other universities require DEI statements and have bloated DEI staffs like UIUC on which they, too, should backtrack. But UIUC seems among the worst with its Communication 9, and it should lead.
UIUC is a superb school in most other ways and an exceptionally valuable research institution. It, along with some of our other universities, are priceless Illinois assets.
They better act before they face the wrath of unhappy donors and Americans fed up with DEI excess.
*Mark Glennon is founder of Wirepoints.
Ivy league college today makes a person less-smart, less-tolerant, more-annoying, more-entitled and miserable to work with. Large corporations are waking up to this and no longer requiring a college education for employment. Especially true in IT where a person who holed up in their basement for 3 years leaning how to develop applications and databases and languages can demand a starting salary over 100K with no college.
One of UIUC’s favorites about to go down hard :
https://www.zerohedge.com/political/ibm-slapped-federal-civil-rights-complaint-after-racist-ceos-obviously-illegal-hiring
Predict this will have significant impact as many Fortune 50 companies like to mimic IBM.
What is it about these people thinking they can flaunt the law and court rulings? Incredible.
They flaunt it because they know that Joe Biden’s junta won’t do a dang thing about it. Like I point out about Chicago’s voter fraud: The last time *anyone* peaked behind the curtain on Chicago’s voter fraud was during Reagan’s administration in 1982, over 41 years ago, and what the Feds found was that Democracy didn’t really exist because of all the fraud. But since then, not one single person has reviewed Chicago for voter fraud, not in 41 years. Last year, a DuPage County clerk filed a lawsuit saying only that it was possible there was fraud because the… Read more »
I’m certain a LOT of the unethical/ woke/ illegal behavior was picked up while at UIUC.
There is fraud in every segment of society where power or money is involved. To think it couldn’t exist in elections shows and absurd level of naivety.
It is truly funny watching academics and lawyers construct a system that dictates speech, thoughts and the very definition of words down to the syllable. These people are nuts. They need to spend a summer having beers at a small town VFW hall and work in a factory and have lunch with a group of UAW, plumber, machinist and electricians workers every day. Then they will be truly educated about thoughts, speech, merit and liberty. Because these blue collar workers and old veterans are ten times smarter and ten times more tolerant.
You’d get better results p***ing into the wind. They have nothing but scorn and contempt for plumbers, machinists, veterans, etc. It’s a cult. Anyone who does not have the appropriate „critical consciousness” mindset to disrupt the racist, patriarchal, etc. systems of oppression is to be steamrolled into submission.
If the taxpayers of Illinois built this school, then it’s mission is to better the condition of Illinois; only Illinois residents should be enrolled in state schools.
Schools court international and out of state students because they pay the out-of-state tuition rate.
Follow the money.
Dah!
If you want Illinois to grow and prosper, then follow Adam Smith’s principals.
Many states limit the number of international ‘students’. In NC they restrict out-of-state AND international students to be no more than 10% of the student body. Also, international students are vetted and must put a sizable sum of ‘earnest $$$’ in escrow so that they can have a means to return to their home country. Sadly, I believe they did away with the loyalty oath for assistantships and fellowships.
DEI mandates in education serve a purpose, indoctrination of educators who will teach it to our children.
As V.I. Lenin said, “Give me four years to teach the children, and the seed I have sown will never be uprooted.”
I have noticed at the medical school I go to that more and more of the Doctors are from other countries. This is probably the way of the future as things like common core math really have no place in advanced science. Because of things like this I have to ponder why Illinois seems like it actually wants to fail these days? Certainly the current education systems from top to bottom are deserving of considerable criticism.
Come on Riverbender, how many times do we have to be told that it’s the parents’ fault?
U of I now stands for University of Illiteracy
Get a degree in anything and don’t even have to get a job. Free money and food stamps for
Life. Ah!!! What a life, pass the malt liquor
I know you say this in jest, and it is funny, but this isn’t totally true. Ever since the private colleges got *really* woke (way more woke than state schools), and private colleges started to blacklist suburban white & asian male students, they all now apply to the Big 10 state schools. It’s a real thing that’s really happening. Even schools like Norte Dame is now ‘diverse’ despite being a historically white irish catholic school. Look at the diversity leader private college Johns Hopkins that, for all practical purposes, stopped accepting most student with white color skin, and has blacklisted… Read more »
My remarks have fallen short, I attended many years ago, family also. As short as
15 years ago some students who entered
Could not sign their own names, but they got some big scholarships.
I don’t financially support them any longer.
Nothing works for the average person
Anymore
You’ve fallen for it – Take out the many thousands of international students, and it begins to look like all the rest at least on paper. UIUC 35 years ago was a great value for in state. It’s been all down hill since. Most good students in IL go out of state. When my daughter applied there to the College of Arts nearly all the people in the room where going to go there no matter what because their options were Normal, or the mediocre directional colleges. OBTW, the acting dean literally plucked dung from her toenails as she took… Read more »
Each year the state of Illinois produces 10-12 national class cross country and track runners at the prep level. This was the case back in my day 45 years ago and remains the same. Illinois is that good. Back in my day, the state champion or runner-up almost invariably went to University of Illinois. This year, none of the top runners are going to Illinois. This has been the case for the past few years. Except for one going to Wisconsin and another to Duke, all are going to schools not nearly as highly ranked as Illinois. This sounds arcane… Read more »
That’s very interesting, things are looking very poorly for IL. It is also probably the ugliest of the Big 10 schools too.
U of IL is one of the wokest out there. U of IL has that professor that says “math iz racisz” and wants to teach math differently to indigenous and other minorities because modern math is too European centric and BIPOC can’t understand it. And then my favorite are the psychology department that is creating a new therapy model that focuses on trauma because of white supremacy and institutionalized racism as the root cause of every individual’s ills. This nonsense has rotted out every department.
Maybe Dementia Joe wouldn’t have to worry about forgiving student loans if there weren’t bloated DEI offices at the campuses across the country. Stop giving to any University that supports this liberal progressive guilt trip garbage. That’s pretty much all of them.
Uh-oh, looks like the fence with all the fat chickens roosting on it is about to finally collapse…
https://www.foxbusiness.com/politics/billionaire-harvard-grad-bill-ackman-suggests-harvard-president-dei-pick
Here’s the letter Ackman wrote to Harvard. https://twitter.com/BillAckman/status/1733985787455168906
Several hundred professors have rallied around President Gay and issued a letter supporting her. Off-the record they’ve basically said that their support of President Gay has little to do with President Gay individually, but rather, they don’t want to give Republicans a ‘win’ removing their president. Think about that for a second. They believe it’s better to support a antisemitic unqualified DEI president than to give Republicans a win in this particular culture battle. However, these people are very bright while at the same time all very stupid. Rallying around a moron of a president to own Republicans looks really,… Read more »
Yet more proof Leftist Democrats are a cult.
To be expected from a school that hired Lori Lightfoot. Lori. Lightfoot.
Garrick currently makes $228K in base compensation and $124K in additional compensation. It would be interesting to know what comprises “additional” compensation and other tidbits about executive compensation in higher ed. I’d wager that the school picks up the employee portion of the pension contribution (assuming they participate at all).
A LOT of state taxpayer $$$ are spent at UIUC, yet many good students are not admitted because of the discriminatory DEI. Although there are several thousands of Asians there, notably from China – it’s been widely reported that nearly all Chinese that come to America to ‘study’ have family CCP and/ or PLA connections. Many states over the last few years have taken steps to end this, as it’s been proven it is an espionage operation.
UIUC is a cesspool of rot, and I don’t see it as any kind of a thing good.
Are universities confident that Qatar will compensate for lost donations from Americans and alumni?
This rot starts at the top. What is the State’s CEO Pritzker stand on this and related issues?
Anything he stands on becomes broken and worthless. LOL
As if you have to ask. You know unequivocally that JB the Hutt bends the knee to the woke mental liberal disordered sociopaths and this extends to his predecessors as well.