Editorial: R.I.P., Metra’s commuter rail. Long live regional rail! – Chicago Tribune*

Chicago commuters catch up on the news on their train on April 28, 1970."On an average weekday, trains have only about 40% of the riders who were there as recently as 2020. That’s a staggering drop-off, and if Metra were a private business, it would be precipitating drastic and immediate change...But Metra’s latest strategic plan, as put together by agency staffers, is far more inspiring and is at least beginning to address the huge change in how this region now is willing to use public transportation. In the document, which is impressive in every way except for its lack of urgency, Metra staffers lay out the only solution: a change from commuter transportation to a true regional rail service."
15 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
nixit
3 years ago

Snowpiercer but with homeless people.

Wolf Larsen
3 years ago
Reply to  nixit

Good movie!

debtsor
3 years ago

I feel dumber after reading this editorial. I legitimately feel stupider. The Trib Editorial Board wants Metra to run more empty trains to places that no one wants to visit by train…Highland Park to Elburn, huh? Why would anyone want to spend an hour and a half on trains to travel between these two places. The Elburn train station is a parking lot in the middle of a cornfield. And of course, they want the trains electrified because of the environment. Do they have idea what it would take to electrify hundreds of miles of Metra lines? Electrified lines are… Read more »

mmack
3 years ago
Reply to  debtsor

I agree with everything you say, and I also laugh about Metra becoming a “regional” train service. And I write this as a former Metra rider. 1) With the infrastructure put in place since the end of the 20th Century, people who do not have a job that MUST be done in a physical location can work from their homes. You can save yourself a couple thousand dollars not having to commute back and forth (train pass and parking). 2) As is abundantly clear, Chicago has a crime problem. An excessive one. Less and less people will be traveling suburbs… Read more »

Henry Hatch
3 years ago
Reply to  mmack

They can call it commuter rail, regional rail or a magic carpet ride if they want to. That doesn’t change the fact that chiraq is dying and the trains in all probability won’t ever recover the passengers lost during the pandemic and made worse by chiraq becoming known by it’s newest industry, uncontrolled crime. The new rail system will be a sucking chest wound that employs over paid friends and family of corrupt politicians, provides unreliable and inconvenient service, and will always operate at a loss requiring huge piles of taxpayer funds to subsidize the declining ridership. Instead of Regional… Read more »

Last edited 3 years ago by Henry Hatch
debtsor
3 years ago
Reply to  mmack

Biden Bux will pay for it all!

The Railroader
3 years ago

Mr. Dabrowski, I have written in this space repeatedly about the ‘jobs for pals’ scheme that Metra became long ago, the ridiculous new equipment overengineered expensively from the wheels up, the empty trains and the spiraling costs. Metra differs from commercial real estate holders only in that it must continue to operate so as to employ the friends and family of Illinois’ politicians. Tell the Chumbolones that they have to pony up for ridiculous and costly battery locomotives, so that the graft can be varnished over by the false religion of the Climate Clerics. Run trains with no one but… Read more »

Rick
3 years ago

Its not so much the crime, its the fact that office work can be done just as productively remotely as in person. Especially IT work and administrative work. Skyscrapers and commuter trains are to a degree obsolete. Thats is neither a good thing or a bad thing, its just a force of nature due to the development of the Internet. Dragging commuters back is futile, thinking creatively is the path to optimizing this infrastructure for something useful again or right-sizing it to use the money elsewhere.

Old Joe
3 years ago

Hmm, no homeless, mentally ill, drunks or pot smokers in this photo from yesteryear.

Old Joe
3 years ago
Reply to  Old Joe

Oops, I forgot panhandlers and public urinators too. Notice the guys are actually wearing ties and business attire.

Surely this is a pic from the 70s.

Eugene from a payphone
3 years ago
Reply to  Old Joe

I must disagree, the Metra lines were always cleaner and more quiet than the CTA rail lines. They were a little pricier than CTA, but you rode with Job Holders who behaved and trainmen and trainwomen who didn’t hesitate to call ahead to meaningful security people. And, as they hit the city limits they highballed it in and out of Chicago with minimal stops.

debtsor
3 years ago

Metra was always nicer than the CTA. The rush hour trains were packed though, standing room only, crammed into the aisles and vestibules. Waiting outside on the platform in -8 weather in mid-February with driving snow in your face every time a delayed express train passed you by at 50 mph. In retrospect, those were horrible times. Then it was a 30 minute train ride, followed by a 12 minute walk on slippery, slushy streets downtown, all to sit a some cubicle 8 to 10 hours a day. I’ll never do this again.

Rick
3 years ago
Reply to  Old Joe

The Young dudes coulda been me then.

Poor Taxpayer
3 years ago

Nothing but homeless and criminals anymore. Decent working people have found another way to get around or just plain move out of the Chitty.

Giddyap
3 years ago

Chicago is a crime infested toilet that decent people avoid. This is a feature, not a ‘bug,” of the Democrat Playbook.

SIGN UP HERE FOR FREE WIREPOINTS DAILY NEWSLETTER

Home Page Signup
First
Last
Check what you would like to receive:

FOLLOW US

 

WIREPOINTS ORIGINAL STORIES

Mark Glennon on AM560’s Morning Answer: Chicago pension buyout plan mostly shifts debt rather than eliminating it, property tax surge doubles inflation over three decades

Chicago’s political leadership is floating a pension buyout program as evidence it is seriously addressing the city’s thirty-six-billion-dollar unfunded pension liability, but Mark Glennon, founder of the Illinois policy research organization Wirepoints, said that the proposal moves debt from one column to another rather than reducing it, and that the broader fiscal picture facing the city continues to deteriorate across every measurable dimension. Audio here.

Read More »

WE’RE A NONPROFIT AND YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS ARE DEDUCTIBLE.

SEARCH ALL HISTORY

CONTACT / TERMS OF USE