The biggest problem with the ‘fair tax’ – Opinion – Crain’s

"First, the progressive income tax would fund just four months of a single year's pension payment. The money would all be spent before even accounting for new spending Pritzker has proposed, such as universal pre-school or a state-run public option health insurance plan." "Second, lawmakers must be honest about why previous, larger tax hikes have failed to deliver on their promises. The 2011 income tax hike was supposed to fix our ballooning unpaid bill backlog and mounting pension debt. The 2017 income tax hike was supposed to balance the budget." "Third, lawmakers must be honest with their constituents about a lack of true reform. Needed constitutional amendments such as term limits, fair political maps, a balanced budget requirement and most important, pension reform, remain absent. The structural problems that have brought the state to the brink remain firmly intact—not to be questioned by voters."
15 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
joe blow
4 years ago

Imagine electing someone like JB (never earned a penny in his life) and expecting your taxes to go down… at any income level… imagine being this dumb and thinking that this clown can spend your hard earned money better than you can

MikeH
4 years ago
Reply to  joe blow

Illinois in a nutshell.

Illinois Entrepreneur
4 years ago

The state gave the democrats the governorship and a supermajority in the legislature. The democrats ran on this platform.

What did people really think was going to happen? That it will somehow all be ok because now that Rauner “the obstructionist who can’t get along” is gone they’ll all get to work with their sleeves rolled up, and come up with magical solutions that will make everyone happy? That the democrats will suddenly turn rightward towards reform, fiscal sanity, and caring about non-public-sector-union middle class people?

Ha!

Tom Paine's Ghost
4 years ago

What an absurd and pointless article. Crains repeatedly says “illinois politicians must honestly….”. Until Illinois finally goes bankrupt, Illinois politicians and honesty will be vastly separated.

Rick
4 years ago

Moody’s has already smiled widely over the tax plan, the markets have blessed it, the sacrificing of taxpayers at the alter of high yields is what the rating agencies are all about. And the fake “just above junk” phrase we always hear is going to be the states reward for continuing the Ponzi. Until the bond holders get a crew cut this is exactly what a well designed colluded “can kick” looks like.

nixit
4 years ago

“But nearly half of Illinois income comes from people making between $50,000 and $200,000 – that means you have a red bull’s-eye on your back pocket already for a tax hike soon to be announced if the progressive amendment passes.”

This needs to be drilled into everyone’s head for the next 12 months.

debtsor
4 years ago
Reply to  nixit

I’ve discussed this with people and all of them just repeat the same line that the law would give the middle class a tax break; and it’s fearmongering and lies that taxes would increase for households between $50,000 and $200,000. I say “come on, we live in IL” and like robots they repeat the same thing.

Willowglen
4 years ago
Reply to  debtsor

The media in Illinois don’t ask any tough questions. Two tax hikes – one in 2011 and another in 2017 – yet the deficit continues to grow. Does it occur to any journalists to ask Pritzker to explain why giving money to the same government run by people with the same tax and spend mindset will bring about anything but higher deficits than before? Like it or not, that is the track record.

debtsor
4 years ago
Reply to  Willowglen

Most voters don’t care or don’t want to know the answers to these tough questions. All they care about is (D) next to their name and it’s a blank check to the politicians. Sometimes the apathy among voters is so infuriating, the only answer is to leave the state. I mean really, the state isn’t worth fixing or even fighting for because its a losing battle; you may as well be a refugee to another state.

world with end
4 years ago

This is a great article that hit the nail on the head!

The only thing I would’ve changed in this and many other articles is replacing the phrases “pension reform” with “pension and health care benefits reform” and “pension liability” with “pension and health care benefits liabilities,” and adjust any related dollar amounts accordingly.

There’s also the issue of bloated salaries, but let’s work that later.

Freddy
4 years ago
Reply to  world with end

I would add that health care that is subsidized by taxpayers the only option should be the basic ACA (obamacare) package not the Platinum version they negotiate without any taxpayer input and it should start under S.S. rules (age 65) not 55 as is the case for many. If they want the platinum care they make up the difference. Taxpayers are mostly on the hook for over $73 Billion in lifetime health benefits for which the prices (RX and medical procedures) are rarely or never negotiated.

Downstate cynic
4 years ago
Reply to  Freddy

When the state is short of cash they delay payments to the contracted health insurers (for government employee and teachers) and Medicaid providers. A significant part of the current ?$ 8 + billion plus in deferred vendor payments is owed to the health insurers. In the past providers and insurers have waited over 12 months for payment. They already pay Medicaid rates at or near the bottom of the nation on a per capital basis for all Medicaid services, in most instances less than 50 % of costs, with hospitals and nursing homes can wait 6-9+ months for payments. It… Read more »

Rick
4 years ago

My doctor won’t accept Medicaid patients, maybe this is why.

MikeH
4 years ago
Reply to  Rick

Rick, a lot of doctors around here won’t, either. And I would imagine that’s the reason, too. It’s not as though their malpractice insurers would accept that sort of thing, so they’ve got money going out either wat

debtsor
4 years ago
Reply to  MikeH

My wife’s hospital is owed literally hundreds of millions of dollars in medicaid money.

SIGN UP HERE FOR FREE WIREPOINTS DAILY NEWSLETTER

Home Page Signup
First
Last
Check all you would like to receive:

FOLLOW US

 

WIREPOINTS ORIGINAL STORIES

WE’RE A NONPROFIT AND YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS ARE DEDUCTIBLE.

SEARCH ALL HISTORY

CONTACT / TERMS OF USE