By: Ted Dabrowski and John Klingner
The perils of letting politicians dole out taxpayer dollars to corporations as investment “incentives” was on full display in Wisconsin recently. New reporting finds that the price tag to taxpayers for winning the Foxconn facility will be $4 billion, not the $3 billion originally reported.
That may leave Wisconsin taxpayers holding the bag for decades – if they ever recoup those costs at all.
Wisconsin politicians last year granted the electronics manufacturing company a reported $3 billion in state tax credits to locate a factory in their state. It’s one of the largest taxpayer-backed incentive packages ever promised to a corporation to locate a facility in the U.S.
While Foxconn’s factory was being celebrated as a major win in Wisconsin, some analysts were already questioning whether the $3 billion subsidy would ever be recouped by taxpayers.
According to the state’s own estimates, it will take until at least 2043 for Wisconsin to recover the costs of the taxpayer subsidies.
And Wisconsin residents are now finding out the price tag is much higher than Wisconsin politicians originally advertised. When all local and state “incentives” given to Foxconn are added up, the sweeteners total more than $4 billion. Local government costs include infrastructure investments in roads and highways, sewer and power lines.
That enormous sum has already had a negative impact on the state’s local governments. As Wirepoints previously reported, Racine County suffered a credit downgrade from Moody’s Investors Service due to the $400 million in incentives its politicians promised Foxconn.
The Foxconn deal is risky for state taxpayers. Whether it will pay off remains to be seen.
Regardless, the deal is still a perfect example for everything wrong with the whole practice of letting politicians hand out taxpayer dollars as a subsidies.
- Politicians get to the pick the economy’s winners and losers. Their preferences decide where state money goes. But it isn’t their money. It’s the taxpayers’ money.
- Politicians shouldn’t have access to that money in the first place. Corporate incentive programs force every resident, entrepreneur and small business to pay higher taxes so that big companies can get big subsidies. It’s simply not fair.
- Companies with lobbyists and connections get the breaks. The ones without them end up paying.
- Corporate handouts may be doled out legally, but it’s a fair bet to say politicians spend taxpayer money far too freely in search of a trophy “deal” for their political campaigns. Foxconn is proof of that.
- Corporate incentives open the door to an enormous amount of cronyism. More than a billion dollars will be spent on local infrastructure as an “incentive” for Foxconn. Land is being donated to the company. Roads are being constructed. Sewer and power lines are being built. These improvements are ripe for the sort of crony deals that leave taxpayers paying for decades.
The bottom line is politicians are gambling with taxpayer money to give corporate handouts.
This all serves as a warning for Illinoisans and their state’s own subsidy programs.
Illinoisans already know their politicians are corrupt. The Berrios-Madigan-Burke property tax assessment scheme in Cook County that enriches politicians and select companies at the expense of poor residents is evidence enough of that.
Do we really want Illinois politicians like House Speaker Mike Madigan, Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel and Gov. Bruce Rauner picking winners and losers directly with taxpayer dollars?
Remember, these are the same politicians that haven’t balanced the budget in 15 years. These are the same politicians that have brought Illinois to the brink of a junk rating. The same ones that have pushed up Illinois taxes to some of the highest levels in the nation.
And these are the same politicians that promised schemes like the EDGE tax credit program would deliver stellar economic returns, but instead have cost taxpayers billions with little result.
Since 2000, the state has spent $1.5 billion on EDGE credits, yet the program has brought in just 37,000 jobs. Rather a poor record considering Illinois still hasn’t created a net new job since the year 2000. In contrast, Illinois’ neighboring states have each added more than 100,000 net new jobs since then.
Bribing a few select companies with others’ tax dollars so they come to Illinois is no way to build a successful economy.
Illinois must instead enact pro-business reforms – including lower taxes – that make the state competitive again. As the nation’s fifth-largest economy, companies should want to be here without needing bribes. And if Illinois thrives, they’ll have to be here if they want to succeed.