By: Ted Dabrowski and John Klingner
You can trust public pension apologists to deflect any critique that calls out the failure of defined benefit plans. Unsurprisingly, their response to a recent Wall Street Journal editorial highlighting Wirepoints’ research was just that – deflection via misdirection and victim playing.
Wirepoints found that a skyrocketing growth in pension benefits, what are known as accrued liabilities, is behind most of the state pension crises playing out across the country. Uncontrolled pension benefit growth is swamping many state economies and the residents who pay for those benefits.
The apologists find the facts inconvenient, so they deflect. They revert to their standard narrative that state governments, and by extension taxpayers, are to blame for “failing to fully fund their public pension commitments.” Or that public employees are the only “victims.” Or they criticize unessential details to distract from the undeniable growth in benefits.
But the apologists don’t disprove the core findings of our research: that unrestrained benefit growth is behind many state fiscal crises.
That was the subject of our two most recent reports: Illinois state pensions: Overpromised, not underfunded and Overpromising has crippled public pensions: A 50-state survey.
The numbers are undeniable. And it’s not just the growth rate of accrued liabilities that’s daunting. It’s how they’re crowding out everything in their path.
Pensions are a drag
Some public pension apologists took issue with the following graphic. They complained that comparing the growth of total pension benefits (accrued liabilities) to the growth in other economic indicators like GDP is “illogical and has no theoretical basis.”
That’s an absurd argument.
The fact is accrued liabilities are a debt – they are the sum of every pension obligation made to all workers and retirees. The growth in that debt over time matters since taxpayers are liable for a large chunk of those promises. If the sum of those promises grows too fast year after year – far faster than an economy (GDP) and its taxpayers (household incomes) can keep up with – a shortfall will invariably occur.
Any person who’s managed a business knows you can’t let a significant debt grow uncontrollably – regardless of why it grows or the math behind it. Left unchallenged, it will bring insolvency. Same goes for a family and its credit card debt.
Yet that’s precisely what’s happening to some states like Illinois, New Jersey and Kentucky.
For example, look at the below chart of Illinois, where Wirepoints has gathered 30 years of pension and state budget data.
It compares the total of Illinois’ state pension promises to the state’s operating budget over time. You’ll quickly see why those promises are swallowing the budget and crowding out spending for everything else.
In 1987, total promises made to active workers and retirees were 1.6 times, or 162%, the size of the state’s yearly operating budget.
By 2016, those total promises had jumped to 6.8 times that of state general fund revenues. That’s outrageous any way you measure it.
How did that happen? The answer lies in the massive growth in the state’s total pension promises – some due to a growth in perks and some due to a more honest reporting of what those promises are really worth.
In 1987, total pension benefits promised to the state’s active workers and retirees was just $18 billion. That’s the total amount of benefits the state’s actuaries calculated were owed by the state.
By 2016, total pension benefits owed had ballooned to $208 billion, according to the Commission on Government Finances and Accounting, the state’s official number crunchers. That’s an increase of 8.8 percent, compounded annually.
In contrast, the state’s tax revenues grew to $30.5 billion in 2016 from $11 billion in 1987. That growth rate was about 3.6 percent a year, or about 36 percent faster than the inflation rate of 2.6 percent annually.
The bottom line: Total pension benefits owed by the state grew 2.5 times faster than state revenues, year after year, for nearly 30 years.
Illinois’ pension growth has dwarfed the growth of everything else in the economy – the state’s GDP (using state personal income as a proxy), the state’s tax revenues and its residents’ ability to pay for them.
It’s little wonder that Illinois pensions are dramatically underfunded. Taxpayer contributions could never keep up with that kind of growth. It’s left Illinois with an officially-reported pension shortfall of $129 billion. And a credit rating that’s just one notch above junk.
While Illinois may be the extreme, other states aren’t far behind.
It’s time to stop blaming taxpayers for the pension mess across the country.
In too many cases, it’s overpromising, and not underfunding, that’s the real cause.
For more information on Illinois pensions:
- Illinois state pensions: Overpromised, not underfunded
- Overpromising has crippled public pensions: A 50-state survey
- Where Illinois’ skyrocketing pension benefits came from
- Harvey, the first domino in Illinois: Data shows nearly 400 other pension funds could trigger garnishment by the state
- A booming market can’t save Illinois pensions